Skip to main content

NEPC Review: Should Students Learn Science Through Inquiry? (American Enterprise Institute, August 2026)

A recent American Enterprise Institute report offers one teacher’s perspective about a core issue in science education: Should Students Learn Science Through Inquiry? The report draws on selected cognitive science research and the teacher’s personal examples to argue instead for explicit instruction of science information. With a narrow focus on knowledge acquisition and memory retrieval, the report recommends a linear, four-step pedagogical model for explicit instruction aimed at mastery of content knowledge. In doing so, however, the report provides examples without context, making it difficult to evaluate how these examples might translate across contexts. Just as importantly, the report ignores key scholarship about how science communities make knowledge, how people learn science through cognition and participation, and how educational aims have been contested. This report is neither an empirical study nor a comprehensive review of research, but rather an argument built primarily from the personal experiences of one science teacher. In a way, this is notable because the perspectives of practicing teachers are so often overlooked in educational policy and decision-making. Nevertheless, the report should only be interpreted for what it is: a firsthand perspective of a single teacher making an argument based on personal perspectives with narrow grounding in research, resulting in very limited guidance for educators and lawmakers. 

Suggested Citation: Braaton, M. (2026). NEPC Review: Should students learn science through inquiry? Boulder, CO: National Education Policy Center. Retrieved [date] from https://nepc.colorado.edu/review/science

Document Reviewed:

Should Students Learn Science Through Inquiry?

Adam Boxer
American Enterprise Institute